A classic old fashioned cocktail typically consists of bourbon, a sugar cube, bitters, and an orange peel or cherry garnish. It’s a perfect drink for those who enjoy the flavor of bourbon but prefer it a bit more approachable. However, there’s a unique variation on this beloved cocktail that hails from Wisconsin, and it’s known as the Wisconsin Old Fashioned.
The Wisconsin Old Fashioned follows a similar foundation but incorporates some controversial additions. Instead of merely using fruit as a garnish, muddled cherries and oranges are combined with the sugar cube and bitters at the bottom of the glass. Brandy often replaces bourbon as the base liquor, and, most notably, the drink is topped with soda. This results in a sweeter, more refreshing take on the traditional old fashioned, making it a popular choice in Wisconsin bars and restaurants.
The choice of soda is crucial when ordering a Wisconsin Old Fashioned. To order like a local, ask for a “Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet?” This indicates a preference for 7-Up or Sprite. Alternatively, you can opt for a “sour,” made with Squirt, sour mix, or occasionally Jolly Good soda, or a “press,” which combines club soda and 7-Up. Each variation offers a distinct flavor profile, catering to different palates.
Experimenting with different sodas is encouraged to discover your preferred Wisconsin Old Fashioned. While club soda provides a drier taste, 7-Up adds a classic sweetness. Jolly Good, a less common option, offers a unique twist. For purists who prefer the traditional recipe, simply ordering a “Bourbon Old Fashioned” will usually suffice. However, be prepared to clarify your preference if the bartender asks, “Sour or Sweet?” This ensures you receive the desired cocktail, whether it’s the classic version or the Wisconsin specialty.
If you’re looking to explore Old Fashion Drink Recipes beyond the traditional, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned offers a delightful and refreshing alternative. Its unique combination of muddled fruit, brandy, and soda creates a complex and satisfying flavor profile that sets it apart. Whether you prefer it sweet, sour, or with a press, the Wisconsin Old Fashioned is a must-try for any cocktail enthusiast.
