The Wisconsin Old Fashioned is a brandy-based cocktail with muddled fruit, bitters, sugar, and a fizzy soda topper. At mens-fashion.net, we want to provide you with the ultimate guide to crafting and ordering this classic Midwestern drink, exploring its unique variations and helping you master the art of creating the perfect Old Fashioned every time, embracing Midwest style. Learn about the history of this iconic beverage, how to make it, and which apparel goes best with a refreshing drink.
1. What Makes a Wisconsin Old Fashioned Unique?
A Wisconsin Old Fashioned stands out due to its use of brandy instead of bourbon, muddled fruit, and a soda topper. A traditional Old Fashioned consists of bourbon, a sugar cube, and a few dashes of bitters, garnished with an orange peel and sometimes a cherry. The Wisconsin version, however, takes a different path by muddling cherries and oranges with the sugar cube and bitters, using brandy as the base spirit, and topping the drink with soda. This creates a sweeter, fizzier, and fruitier cocktail. The muddled fruit adds a layer of sweetness and complexity, while the brandy offers a smoother, slightly sweeter alternative to bourbon. The soda adds a refreshing fizz, making it a lighter and more approachable drink. This variation is particularly popular in Wisconsin and reflects the state’s unique cocktail culture.
1.1. Brandy Over Bourbon
Brandy is preferred over bourbon because it offers a different flavor profile that many Wisconsinites enjoy. Brandy is often smoother and slightly sweeter than bourbon, which can be bolder and spicier. This makes the Old Fashioned more approachable for those who prefer a less intense spirit. According to a 2018 article in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, brandy became popular in Wisconsin due to the state’s large German population, who had a preference for brandy. The Korbel Brandy company heavily promoted its product in Wisconsin, leading to its widespread adoption in cocktails like the Old Fashioned.
1.2. Muddled Fruit
The muddling of fruit, typically cherries and oranges, introduces a distinct sweetness and fruity aroma that distinguishes it from the traditional recipe. The muddled fruit releases its natural sugars and oils, creating a more complex and flavorful drink. This technique enhances the overall taste and adds a visual appeal. Muddled fruit is essential to the Wisconsin Old Fashioned because it infuses the drink with a depth of flavor that a simple garnish cannot achieve.
1.3. Soda Topper
The choice of soda – sweet (7-Up or Sprite), sour (Squirt), or press (club soda or half 7-Up and half club soda) – adds a customizable fizz and sweetness level. The soda topper is a key component that lightens the drink and makes it more refreshing. Each option offers a different taste experience, allowing drinkers to tailor the cocktail to their preferences. For instance, a “sweet” Old Fashioned is sweeter and more dessert-like, while a “sour” Old Fashioned has a tangy edge.
2. How to Order a Wisconsin Old Fashioned Like a Local
To order a Wisconsin Old Fashioned like a true Wisconsinite, specify your soda preference when you order. Instead of simply asking for an Old Fashioned, use the phrase: “Can I have a brandy Old Fashioned sweet (or sour, or press)?”
2.1. “Sweet” Explained
Ordering it “sweet” means your drink will be topped with 7-Up or Sprite, adding a sugary flavor. This version is for those who enjoy a sweeter, more dessert-like cocktail. The sweetness of the soda complements the brandy and muddled fruit, creating a balanced and enjoyable drink. This is a popular choice in Wisconsin due to its approachable and crowd-pleasing flavor profile.
2.2. “Sour” Defined
Requesting it “sour” means it will be made with Squirt or a sour mix, offering a tangy contrast to the sweetness. The sour mix cuts through the sweetness of the brandy and muddled fruit, providing a more balanced and refreshing taste. Some bars might use Jolly Good soda if available, adding a local touch. This is a great option for those who prefer a less sweet and more tart cocktail.
2.3. “Press” Unveiled
Opting for “press” means it will be mixed with club soda or a combination of half club soda and half 7-Up, resulting in a lighter, less sweet beverage. The club soda adds a subtle fizz without overwhelming the other flavors, while the half-and-half mix provides a balanced level of sweetness and carbonation. This is an excellent choice for those who want to enjoy the flavors of the brandy and muddled fruit without excessive sweetness.
3. The Ultimate Wisconsin Old Fashioned Recipe
Crafting the perfect Wisconsin Old Fashioned at home involves a few key steps and quality ingredients. Here’s a detailed recipe to guide you:
Ingredients:
- 2 ounces of brandy (Korbel is a popular choice)
- 1 sugar cube (or 1 teaspoon of sugar)
- 2-3 dashes of Angostura bitters
- 1 orange slice
- 2-3 maraschino cherries
- Your choice of soda: 7-Up, Sprite, Squirt, or club soda
- Orange peel for garnish (optional)
Instructions:
- Muddle: In an old-fashioned glass, place the sugar cube, bitters, orange slice, and cherries. Muddle them together until the sugar is dissolved and the fruit is well mashed.
- Add Brandy: Pour the brandy over the muddled mixture.
- Add Ice: Fill the glass with ice cubes.
- Top with Soda: Add your choice of soda to fill the glass.
- Garnish: Garnish with an orange peel and additional cherry, if desired.
This recipe provides a balanced and flavorful Old Fashioned that captures the essence of the Wisconsin version. Adjust the sweetness and sourness by experimenting with different sodas and the amount of muddled fruit to find your perfect balance.
3.1. Ingredient Selection: The Key to Success
Choosing the right ingredients is crucial for creating an authentic and delicious Wisconsin Old Fashioned. High-quality brandy, fresh fruit, and the right bitters can elevate your cocktail to the next level.
3.2. Mastering the Muddle
Muddling is more than just mashing ingredients; it’s about extracting the flavors and oils to create a rich base for your cocktail. Learn the proper technique to release the full potential of the fruit and sugar. Proper muddling is essential because it ensures that the flavors of the fruit, sugar, and bitters are fully integrated, creating a well-balanced and flavorful drink. The goal is to gently press and twist the ingredients to release their juices and oils without over-muddling, which can result in a bitter taste.
3.3. Choosing Your Soda
The soda you choose can drastically change the flavor profile of your Old Fashioned. Understand the nuances of each option to create your perfect drink. Each soda option offers a unique twist to the cocktail, allowing you to customize it to your preferences. Experimenting with different sodas can help you discover new flavor combinations and create your signature version of the Wisconsin Old Fashioned.
4. Variations on the Classic Recipe
While the traditional Wisconsin Old Fashioned is a beloved drink, there are several variations that offer unique twists on the classic recipe. These variations can include different types of fruit, alternative sweeteners, and even different spirits.
4.1. The Cranberry Old Fashioned
Adding cranberry juice or muddled cranberries can introduce a tart and festive flavor, perfect for holiday gatherings. The cranberry adds a vibrant color and a refreshing tartness that complements the sweetness of the brandy and muddled fruit. This variation is particularly popular during the fall and winter months, offering a seasonal twist on the classic cocktail.
4.2. The Maple Old Fashioned
Using maple syrup instead of sugar adds a rich, caramel-like sweetness that pairs well with brandy. The maple syrup infuses the drink with a warm and inviting flavor, enhancing the overall taste experience. This variation is perfect for those who enjoy a more complex and nuanced sweetness in their cocktails.
4.3. The Cherry Old Fashioned
Increasing the amount of muddled cherries or using cherry brandy can intensify the fruity notes of the drink. The cherry flavor adds a rich and luscious sweetness to the cocktail, making it a decadent and indulgent treat. This variation is ideal for cherry lovers who want to enhance the fruity aspects of the Old Fashioned.
5. Pairing Your Old Fashioned with the Perfect Outfit
An Old Fashioned isn’t just a drink; it’s an experience. Enhance that experience by pairing it with the right attire. Whether you’re at a casual bar or a sophisticated lounge, your outfit can complement the drink and elevate your style.
5.1. Casual Cool
For a relaxed setting, pair your Old Fashioned with a classic button-down shirt, dark denim jeans, and leather boots. This combination is comfortable, stylish, and perfect for a laid-back evening. Add a well-fitted denim jacket for an extra layer of style and warmth.
5.2. Smart Casual
Elevate your look with a blazer, chinos, and dress shoes. This smart-casual ensemble is versatile and suitable for a variety of occasions. A navy or gray blazer pairs well with chinos in beige or olive, creating a sophisticated yet approachable appearance. Accessorize with a stylish watch and a pocket square for added flair.
5.3. Sophisticated Evening
For a more formal setting, opt for a suit or a tailored jacket with dress pants. A dark-colored suit, such as navy or charcoal, is a timeless choice that exudes elegance and confidence. Pair it with a crisp white dress shirt, a silk tie, and polished dress shoes. A well-chosen pocket square can add a touch of personality to your outfit.
6. The History of the Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned has a rich history that dates back to the 19th century. Understanding its origins can deepen your appreciation for this classic cocktail.
6.1. The Birth of the Cocktail
The term “cocktail” originally referred to a specific type of mixed drink, characterized by the combination of spirits, sugar, water, and bitters. The Old Fashioned is considered one of the original cocktails, embodying this simple yet elegant formula. According to cocktail historian David Wondrich, the Old Fashioned emerged as a way to enjoy spirits in a more palatable and sophisticated manner.
6.2. The Pendennis Club
The Old Fashioned as we know it today is often attributed to the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky. In the late 19th century, bartender James E. Pepper, a member of the club, is said to have created the drink in honor of a distinguished whiskey distiller. The recipe quickly gained popularity and spread throughout the country, becoming a staple in bars and clubs.
6.3. Wisconsin’s Unique Twist
The Wisconsin Old Fashioned evolved as a regional variation, reflecting the state’s unique tastes and preferences. The use of brandy, muddled fruit, and soda reflects the influence of German immigrants and the local cocktail culture. This variation showcases how a classic cocktail can be adapted and customized to suit local tastes, creating a distinctive and beloved drink.
7. Where to Find the Best Old Fashioneds in Wisconsin
If you’re looking to experience the best Wisconsin Old Fashioneds, there are several bars and restaurants throughout the state that are renowned for their expertly crafted versions.
7.1. Milwaukee Hotspots
Milwaukee, being the largest city in Wisconsin, boasts a vibrant bar scene with numerous establishments serving exceptional Old Fashioneds. Bryant’s Cocktail Lounge, known for its extensive cocktail menu and vintage ambiance, is a must-visit for cocktail enthusiasts. The Milwaukee Art Museum also offers stunning views and a refined atmosphere to enjoy a classic Old Fashioned.
7.2. Madison Gems
Madison, the state’s capital, offers a mix of cozy pubs and upscale restaurants where you can find expertly made Old Fashioneds. The Old Fashioned, a bar dedicated to the classic cocktail, is a must-visit for enthusiasts. Tornado Steak House, known for its supper club atmosphere, also serves a fantastic Old Fashioned.
7.3. Supper Clubs
Wisconsin supper clubs are a quintessential part of the state’s culinary culture, and many of them serve excellent Old Fashioneds. These establishments often have a nostalgic charm and a commitment to classic recipes, making them perfect for experiencing the authentic Wisconsin Old Fashioned. The Buckhorn Supper Club and Ishnala Supper Club are particularly known for their Old Fashioneds and scenic locations.
8. The Art of Garnishing
Garnishing is an essential part of creating a visually appealing and aromatic Old Fashioned. The right garnish can enhance the overall drinking experience.
8.1. Classic Orange Peel
A classic orange peel is a staple garnish for an Old Fashioned, adding a citrusy aroma and a touch of bitterness. To create the perfect orange peel garnish, use a vegetable peeler to remove a strip of peel from an orange. Express the oils by gently squeezing the peel over the drink, and then rub the rim of the glass with the peel before placing it in the cocktail.
8.2. Maraschino Cherry
A maraschino cherry adds a pop of color and a touch of sweetness to the Old Fashioned. Opt for high-quality cherries that are not overly processed or artificially flavored. Luxardo cherries are a popular choice among bartenders for their rich flavor and natural sweetness.
8.3. Seasonal Garnishes
Consider using seasonal garnishes to add a unique twist to your Old Fashioned. In the fall, a cinnamon stick or a star anise can add warmth and spice. In the summer, a sprig of mint or a slice of fresh fruit can provide a refreshing touch.
9. The Old Fashioned in Pop Culture
The Old Fashioned has made numerous appearances in pop culture, cementing its status as a timeless and iconic cocktail.
9.1. Mad Men
The AMC television series “Mad Men” played a significant role in reviving the popularity of the Old Fashioned. The show’s protagonist, Don Draper, is frequently seen ordering and enjoying Old Fashioneds, showcasing the drink’s sophistication and classic appeal. The show’s attention to detail and authentic portrayal of the 1960s cocktail culture helped reintroduce the Old Fashioned to a new generation of drinkers.
9.2. Film and Literature
The Old Fashioned has appeared in numerous films and literary works, often as a symbol of elegance, tradition, and good taste. Its presence in these cultural artifacts underscores its enduring appeal and its association with a certain level of sophistication. From classic movies to contemporary novels, the Old Fashioned continues to be a drink of choice for characters who appreciate the finer things in life.
9.3. Modern Revival
The resurgence of cocktail culture in recent years has led to a renewed interest in classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned. Bartenders and mixologists are experimenting with new variations and techniques, while still honoring the drink’s rich history and tradition. This modern revival has helped the Old Fashioned remain relevant and appealing to a wide range of drinkers.
10. Frequently Asked Questions About the Wisconsin Old Fashioned
Here are some frequently asked questions about the Wisconsin Old Fashioned, providing quick answers to common queries.
10.1. What is the main difference between a regular Old Fashioned and a Wisconsin Old Fashioned?
The main differences are the use of brandy instead of bourbon, muddled fruit, and a soda topper in the Wisconsin version.
10.2. What does “sweet” mean when ordering an Old Fashioned in Wisconsin?
“Sweet” means the drink will be topped with 7-Up or Sprite.
10.3. Can I use bourbon instead of brandy in a Wisconsin Old Fashioned?
While not traditional, you can use bourbon if you prefer, but it will change the flavor profile.
10.4. What are the best bitters to use in an Old Fashioned?
Angostura bitters are the most traditional and widely used, but you can experiment with other flavors like orange or cherry bitters.
10.5. How do I muddle fruit properly?
Gently press and twist the fruit to release its juices and oils without over-muddling.
10.6. What is the best type of ice for an Old Fashioned?
Large ice cubes or spheres are ideal as they melt slower, keeping the drink colder for longer without diluting it too quickly.
10.7. Can I make an Old Fashioned without sugar?
You can use maple syrup or agave nectar as a substitute, but it will alter the flavor.
10.8. What are some good food pairings for an Old Fashioned?
The Old Fashioned pairs well with rich and savory foods like steak, grilled meats, and aged cheeses.
10.9. How do I make a non-alcoholic Old Fashioned?
Use a non-alcoholic spirit alternative, muddle the fruit as usual, and top with soda.
10.10. What is a “press” when ordering an Old Fashioned?
“Press” means the drink will be mixed with club soda or a combination of half club soda and half 7-Up.
Ready to explore more about men’s fashion and find the perfect style to complement your favorite Wisconsin Old Fashioned? Visit mens-fashion.net for the latest trends, expert advice, and inspiration to elevate your wardrobe! Discover the perfect outfit for every occasion and stay ahead of the fashion curve. Contact us at Address: 227 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001, United States or Phone: +1 (212) 217-5800.
