Fashion is subjective, sparking diverse opinions and sometimes, harsh critiques. E!’s Fashion Police capitalized on this, offering a comedic yet often controversial commentary on celebrity style. The show’s panel, featuring Giuliana Rancic, Kelly Osbourne, and George Kotsiopolous, brought a mix of expertise from entertainment journalism, celebrity lineage, and styling. This dynamic fostered lively debates and often conflicting viewpoints, making for engaging television. Their willingness to stand by their convictions, even when dissenting opinions arose, added to the show’s authenticity.
Celebrity appearances on Fashion Police provided insight into their personalities beyond the red carpet. Guests often revealed a more down-to-earth side, challenging preconceived notions based solely on their public image. Amber Rose, for example, demonstrated that personal style doesn’t define character. These interactions humanized celebrities, reminding viewers that they are individuals with complexities beyond their fashion choices.
While Joan Rivers brought comedic experience, her humor sometimes veered into offensive and repetitive territory. Her often vulgar jokes and predictable bits detracted from the show’s overall quality. The discomfort of other panelists, particularly Giuliana Rancic, during Rivers’ more outrageous moments was palpable. The inclusion of Rivers’ daughter, Melissa, felt forced, further contributing to the show’s shortcomings.
Despite its flaws, Fashion Police offered engaging segments like “Starlet or Streetwalker” and “Guess Me From Behind,” injecting humor and lightheartedness into the critiques. The panelists often provided insightful advice on improving outfits, demonstrating their fashion knowledge. Their judgments, generally objective, focused on individual potential rather than resorting to personal attacks based on weight, age, or eccentricities. While occasional “b!tchy” comments surfaced, the panel primarily aimed to assess whether individuals looked their best.
